Monday, March 4, 2013

IRMA Statement on VOICE Results

[Click here for the VOICE press release - "Daily HIV Prevention Approaches Didn’t Work for African Women in the VOICE Study" - from the Microbcide Trials Network]

IRMA, like the rest of new prevention technology researchers and advocates, is disappointed to learn that daily oral Truvada was not found to be an effective HIV intervention among the African women at risk for HIV who participated in the VOICE trial.

We applaud the efforts of the 5,029 women from South Africa, Zimbabwe, and Uganda who volunteered to participate in the VOICE trial. We also commend the Microbicide Trials Network and the National Institutes of Health for successfully executing this extraordinarily ambitious, important trial, and for contributing critical new information to the field.

Today at CROI 2013 we learned that the majority of women in the daily oral Truvada arm of VOICE were not taking their drugs regularly if at all. Rather than a biological explanation, it appears daily oral Truvada was not effective at preventing HIV among the women in the VOICE trial because the drug was not used regularly.

The results of VOICE indicate low adherence to all the drugs/regimens tested in the trial. There was also low adherence in the daily oral tenofovir and daily tenofovir gel arms. Both these arms were closed due to futility in late 2011 after separate reviews by the independent Data Safety and Monitoring Board. VOICE’s daily oral Truvada arm remained open until August 2012.

One of the biggest challenges the field faces is that of adherence. Clinical trials cannot show that a drug works to prevent HIV if trial participants do not take the drug. More must be done to accurately assess adherence during clinical trials in “real time”, and more must be done to develop HIV prevention interventions that people actually want to use, and like to use. But, we won’t be able to refine the drugs, the drug dosing strategies, and/or the drug delivery vehicles to make them more acceptable if trial participants are not adherent along the way.

Science is an iterative process. We are in the “car phone” phase of new prevention technologies - some of the drugs and dosing strategies are perhaps a little clunky. We all want to get to the “i-Phone” phase where we have interventions that are highly acceptable, and desired, but we won’t get there without going through the clunky phase first.

As the field moves forward, issues of recruitment are as important as adherence. Identifying potential trial participants who are most likely to be adherent during the trial is absolutely critical – and very challenging, as the way to achieve this is admittedly not clear.

The MTN-017 trial, a Phase II safety and acceptability study testing a reduced glycerin formulation of tenofovir gel, is getting ready to launch in the coming months. The study will enroll 186 gay men and transgender women at sites in Thailand, South Africa, Peru, and the United States, including Puerto Rico. It will be absolutely essential that MTN-017 volunteers take the study drugs as directed. If adherence is low during this trial, adequate amounts of safety data will not be collected, making it likely that efforts to develop tenofovir gel as a rectal microbicide will be halted permanently. Have no doubt, this would be a huge setback for rectal microbicide research, development, and advocacy efforts in general.

IRMA is very supportive of MTN-017’s inclusion of “real time” monitoring to assess adherence throughout the trial. This will allow investigators to understand and address challenges regarding adherence while the trial is underway, and will help participants make appropriate adjustments in “real time” to improve adherence outcomes. MTN-017 sites should also pay extra special attention to recruitment activities and work to engage and enroll individuals who are most likely to fully participate in the trial, and follow the various regimens being tested as directed.


*Join IRMA's robust, highly-active. moderated, global listserv addressing rectal microbicide research and advocacy as well as other interesting new HIV prevention technologies by contacting us at Joining our listserv automatically makes you a member of IRMA - a network of more than 1,100 advocates, scientists, policy makers and funders from all over the world.

*Please look for us on Facebook:, and you can follow us on Twitter: @rectalmicro.

*Also, please note that shared news items from other sources posted on this blog do not necessarily mean IRMA has taken any position on the article's content.


No comments:

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...